Why Is The Crypto Community Upset With The US Infra Bill?

By September 7, 20214 minute read
Why Is The Crypto Community Upset With The US Infra Bill?

Note: This blog is written by an external blogger. The views and opinions expressed within this post belong solely to the author.

The US Senate introduced a $1.2 Trillion Infrastructure Bill on 1 August, which disturbed the crypto world. It is assumed that the Bill could prevent investors from performing crypto business in the US and even cause some companies to shut down or move out of the crypto game. 

US Infra Bill in short

The bipartisan infrastructure Bill worth trillion dollars, introduced by the US senators, is among one of the biggest public works legislation in the past few decades. This Bill concentrates on building roads, bridges, ports, and high-speed internet, etc. 

According to the US Senators, the Bill commends into 2,702 pages through which the US government is expected to bring in $30 Billion by consolidating tax reporting requirements on cryptocurrency. Also, they have introduced the term ‘broker’  with a comprehensive definition that created unrest among the crypto community. The crypto insiders have evaluated the term ‘broker’ as bad news for crypto investors.


Definition of broker

There’s a huge disagreement regarding the introduction of the definition of the term “broker.” There is a provision, which would specify a “broker” as any person who delivers a service or conducts transfers of digital assets on behalf of another person. 

Many questions are arising from the industry participants as there might be the possibility that this “broker” term would include non-custodial companies, like decentralized exchanges and miners. This eventually would make them unfit to file broker-specific tax reporting forms.

The Bill is supposed to be an effort in regulating uncollected taxes developed due to crypto, which according to the IRS Commissioner Charles P. Rettig, would be around $28 Billion to $30 Billion. Though, the draft does not influence IRS-regulated platforms or any source areas through which people might purchase cryptocurrency like Square, PayPal, Robinhood, etc. According to the notified guidelines, such platforms will not be affected by the Bill.   

Significance of the term broker in the crypto community

As per the infrastructure Bill, any business involving digital transactions or digital asset transfer is considered a broker. This implies that any individual, including software developers, miners, investors, etc., can be recognized as a broker.

According to the Bill, crypto brokers will be obliged to register customer information to the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). The draft directs the brokers to reveal the digital asset transactions of more than $10,000 to the IRS. 

Moreover, Crypto sellers will have to report to the IRS about every purchase as well as the sales price. The Bill has provisions for a strict crackdown regarding “crypto tax evasions.” Apart from the strictly strong clauses, the language is considered to be another problem by broadening the definition of ‘broker.’

General views on Infra Bill 

The Blockchain Association stated that the draft’s language acts as an “imminent threat” to the growing crypto industry. As per the association, the tax charges generated by crypto could be much less than what is displayed by the IRS.

Since everyone knows that the crypto sector experienced a serious blow after China cracked down on the crypto industry. Further, this caused more than half of mining operations to move out of the country to the US. And hence this Bill is about to affect the crypto world on a significant basis.

Why is the crypto community unhappy with the infrastructure Bill?

In a recent situation in the lobbying battle,  a proposal was included in the infrastructure Bill.


Areas of concern:

  • This proposal recognized cryptocurrency trading platforms and other entities as “brokers” that must report every digital asset transaction to the Internal Revenue Service, which causes the eventual revealing of all the critical data to the IRS. This has created insecurities in the crypto community regarding privacy and data safety.
  • It was addressed that cryptocurrency traders fail to pay the taxes, which created unrest among the crypto community. It has been assumed that through this Bill, lawmakers and the administration incorporated certain provisions to raise revenue for infrastructure projects. 
  • Digital currencies like Bitcoin and Ether enable the user to make financial transactions without using fiat currency like the US  dollar; hence the cryptocurrency has become a tool for investment and speculation. Implementation of taxes on these transactions under this Bill is unfair, according to the crypto investors. 
  • Digital currency advocates and lobbyists immediately expressed denial against the tax provision. They have assumed the infra Bill as a threat to the crypto industry’s existence in the US. 
  • They also warned that it is tough to accept the reporting rules for the software developers and miners that help validate transactions on the computer networks underlying virtual currencies. 
  • It also threatened the development of decentralized online finance and services that offer to trade on automated software protocols with minimum human supervision.
  • The provision did not implement a new tax, but the issue is with an expanded broker definition that crosses the usual limits of similar financial sectors.

Bottom line

The tax proposal revealed on 28 July surprised many industry advocates and is declared as the most powerful piece of legislation to target cryptocurrency in a short time. The vote on this Bill is about to happen in the coming days. 

Lobby groups in Washington are already suggesting revisions. Government regulations are welcomed as a source of innovation, but such critical regulations must be planned carefully with balanced legislation.

Disclaimer: Cryptocurrency is not a legal tender and is currently unregulated. Kindly ensure that you undertake sufficient risk assessment when trading cryptocurrencies as they are often subject to high price volatility. The information provided in this section doesn't represent any investment advice or WazirX's official position. WazirX reserves the right in its sole discretion to amend or change this blog post at any time and for any reasons without prior notice.
Participate in the Indian Crypto Movement. Share:

Leave a Reply

WazirX NewsLetter


What do you get?

● Blockchain & Crypto specific news, updates, tips, contest alerts and more.

● Insights about what is happening at WazirX.

● One email per week. No spamming - We promise!